Another book I’m reading at the moment is called Metamagical Themas which is an anagram of Mathematical Games. It’s a book of articles written by a guy called Douglas R. Hofstadter which were originally published over several years in Scientific American. There’s some really great stuff in it.
One little concept which I really liked was in an article about the uncertainty principle. Actually there were two great concepts:
Firstly, a popular explanation of the uncertainty principle in physics (which is that there are pairs of properties which can’t be simultaneously known — they don’t commute, eg. position and momentum cannot be simultaneously known. If you know the position of something you cannot possibly know it’s velocity exactly) is that of likening it to a coin falling down the couch. It’s about measurements. Whenever you stick your hand down the couch to get the coin, the act of measuring causes the coin to fall further, and so the measurement disrupts the system. He explains that this is a poor analogy, and shouldn’t be taken too seriously. Nevertheless, it is a nice little explanation of the destructive capacity of probing a system.
The second nice little thing he talked about was breakthrough in science.
He said that people are often sceptical of new fundamental theories (think atoms, then electrons and protons, then quarks and gluons, and now string theory). The nice little thing he said was that a new, more fundamental theory, should always be strikingly weird, and completely different to the old theory. He says that if you zoomed in on a solid and just saw a solid, then that wouldn’t be a new theory and it wouldn’t explain anything. He says that what does happen – that you zoom in on a solid and see an array of balls arranged in a regular way with electrons buzzing about them – is so weird that it’s exactly what we should expect to see. It explains the structure of the (relatively) macroscopic observation/material/whatever.
I really like this perspective. It helps me to accept that perhaps string theory is exactly what’s going on, and makes me wonder how zoomed in we can go.









